#106: How to Know If Your Interview Process Works
Your team filled the role. Everyone submitted their feedback. But can you tell whether your interview process helped you choose someone who can actually do the job?
Textio's CEO, Colleen Gallagher joins Rhona Pierce to explore how to know if your interview process works, and why so many recruiting teams struggle to answer that question. Drawing on the State of Interview Intelligence report from Textio and Kyle & Co., they discuss the gap between employers’ confidence in their interviews and candidates’ experience of going through them.
They dig into why AI-generated notes can leave hiring decisions based on gut feel, how to assess candidates consistently while keeping interviews conversational, and what teams could learn by connecting interview evidence to performance after the hire.
Colleen also explains how Textio approached building Lavalier, including live guidance that helps interviewers ask follow-up questions and collect clearer evidence of candidates’ skills.
What you’ll learn:
- What to look at beyond time-to-fill when evaluating your interview process
- How to connect interview evidence with performance after the hire
- Why AI summaries alone may leave hiring decisions unchanged
- How to keep structured interviews conversational
- How recruiters can use interview data to coach hiring managers
Sponsor & Resources
- Download the State of Interview Intelligence Report: https://workfluencerpodcast.com/textio
- Listen to Colleen's Podcast: https://thetalentbarpodcast.com/
- Subscribe to my Newsletter: https://link.rhonapierce.com/newsletter2
Connect with Us:
- Connect with Colleen: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colleengallagher/
- Connect with Rhona: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rhonabarnettpierce
Want to turn your team into creators?
Visit workfluencermedia.com to learn how we help companies turn employee expertise into content that gets noticed.
FAQs
How do you know if your interview process works?
Compare the evidence collected during interviews with how people perform after they’re hired. Start with the skills identified at intake. Review whether interviewers assessed those skills and whether the evidence they recorded aligns with performance six to nine months later. Time-to-fill and completed scorecards alone won’t tell you whether interviews helped you make a good hiring decision.
What should you measure to evaluate your interview process?
Look at whether interviews collect evidence of job-relevant skills, whether candidates are assessed consistently, and how interview findings relate to performance after hiring. Candidate feedback can also reveal gaps in preparation, communication, and treatment that your internal process metrics may miss.
Why aren’t AI interview notes enough to improve hiring decisions?
AI notes capture what was said, but teams still need to evaluate whether a candidate demonstrated the skills required for the job. A detailed summary can leave the underlying decision unchanged if interviewers continue to rely on personal impressions or fail to compare evidence against agreed hiring criteria.
How can you make structured interviews feel conversational?
Use consistent skills and assessment criteria while allowing follow-up questions to fit each candidate’s answers. If someone says they led a project, ask what they personally owned, which decisions they made, and how they measured results. The aim is to collect comparable evidence while giving candidates room to explain their experience.
What tools can help hiring managers ask better interview questions?
Lavalier by Textio is one option discussed in this episode. Colleen Gallagher explains that its live guidance helps interviewers ask follow-up questions tied to the skills they need to assess. That includes probing for specific examples, individual contributions, and results when an initial answer lacks detail.
How can AI help teams assess candidates more consistently?
AI can help interviewers collect evidence against shared job requirements and identify where an answer needs further exploration. In this episode, Colleen Gallagher describes how Lavalier by Textio provides live guidance to help different interviewers assess the same skills across candidates. Hiring teams still need to review that evidence and make the decision.
How can recruiters use interview data to advise hiring managers?
Recruiters can compare interview evidence from past hires with later performance and bring those findings into hiring discussions. For example, they could identify skills that stronger performers demonstrated during interviews and help hiring managers assess those skills more deliberately in future candidates.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Rhona Pierce (00:00.12)
Have we reintroduced a lot of the bias that we had already removed from the process?
Colleen Gallagher (00:05.326)
I believe that we probably hadn't removed as much bias as we thought.
Rhona Pierce (00:10.208)
If interview intelligence delivers on its promise, what changes for talent acquisition?
Colleen Gallagher (00:15.47)
A recruiter should be the quarterback, and I don't believe that's true.
Rhona Pierce (00:18.84)
How do we actually know whether our interview is
Colleen Gallagher (00:21.474)
Yeah, I think right now the honest answer is
Rhona Pierce (00:25.454)
Thanks to Textio for sponsoring this episode. Sorry to break it to you, but the TA industry might have a self-awareness problem. Employers think their interview process is great. Candidates, not so much. And despite all the technology we've thrown at hiring, we're still struggling to answer one pretty important question. Are we making better hiring decisions? Today, I'm joined by Colleen Gallagher.
CEO of Textio to chat about what Textio's new state of interview intelligence report reveals about our industry's biggest blind spots and why interview intelligence could change the way we hire. Colleen, welcome to Workfluencer. Thanks for having me. So for folks who haven't met you yet, what's the Colleen story in like 30 seconds?
Colleen Gallagher (01:11.108)
okay, talking about me in 30 seconds or less. Let's see. You know, I started my career in finance, and I think everyone thought that that was a very natural place for me to be. And so I have pivoted in terms of where I've gone in my career, and I've largely been at companies that our customers are in the HR space. And I think that has resonated a lot with me because I think functions like finance and HR often get grouped into this. You're just helping in the back office, and where I think
The reality is such that those are should be the two most powerful parts of the organization because they have the ability to look across the entire company in a way that no one else does. And so when you have the folks who are managing the financial investments of the organization and you have the people who are managing the people of the organization, I think there's just a lot of
similarities and and a lot of things that you can really learn about how a business operates by having those those viewpoints. And so I you know, I love the the the HR space and and just learning about what our customers need.
Rhona Pierce (02:20.278)
Amazing. And as I said, we're talking about this new state of interview intelligence report. Why was it important for you guys to have this report made?
Colleen Gallagher (02:29.774)
You know, I think what we have benefited from over the last decade plus that Textio has been around is we've worked with so many really amazing talent acquisition teams and recruiters. And we have just constantly heard, you know, some of the biggest challenges are around interviews. I mean, I think about it, you you do all this work up front, you help put together a slate of candidates, and then you sort of
set everything off and you have no information about what's actually happening within the conversations that people are having. And and this is where my finance background gets, you know, like red light, alert, alert, is like nobody has any real information as to how we're making those hiring decisions. And what we've heard constantly from recruiters is we have to have a better way of understanding and really being the thought partner and strategic partner to hiring managers. And what I like to think about is
You have to bring your subject matter experts and hiring together in a way that also brings the subject matter experts of the function. And I think right now we're also at a very important time in the development of technology where we have the ability to do that in a way that can really benefit everyone in the organization. And yet I think that there are some misperceptions or missed opportunities when we look at what's happening right now.
Rhona Pierce (03:50.35)
What stood out the most to you from the report?
Colleen Gallagher (03:54.2)
Gosh, I think there's a couple things that really resonated or stood out to me in the report. There's a huge disconnect between how candidates perceive their experience and how recruiters and talent acquisition leaders and HR leaders in general perceive the experience. And so what that tells me is we haven't quite nailed it yet, right? I I think a lot of people will say, well, you know, candidates are just always gonna have a lesser opinion because most of them don't get the job.
And that's true, but if you actually look at what the data says, it's not about whether or not they got the job, it's how they were treated during the experience. And there are so many opportunities we have now to help with that. And yet a lot of what we're seeing is just not actually having the impact that we expect it to.
Rhona Pierce (04:45.518)
Are you surprised by that disconnect in the the results? Like you talk to people all day about their interview and their interview process.
Colleen Gallagher (04:56.014)
I think I was surprised at the why behind it. Not necessarily that there was a disconnect, but that the the perception is not about whether or not somebody got the job. It's about how they were treated. Which in some respects, it's like, that's so obvious, right? But I think we allow ourselves, I've I've done this as a hiring manager and I, you know, I see it, it's it's not just a TA thing, is well, they must be upset because they didn't get the job. And it's like, no, they're
You know, they wanna be treated, they wanna be seen. People just wanna be seen in the process. And, you know, we have the opportunity to bring the two parties that are involved in, you know, the company and the people in the hiring process together in a way that's going to be better for both. And I think right now we're not seeing, we're not seeing it manifest in the results that we wanna have.
Rhona Pierce (05:47.394)
I think one thing that stood out to me from the report is the the disconnect or or like how confident employers are that their interviews predict job performance. It made me wonder how do we actually know whether our interviews work?
Colleen Gallagher (06:04.952)
Yeah, I think right now the honest answer is we don't. And I think that is the huge opportunity. You know, the the thing that I have been spending a lot of time thinking about, and what I'm starting to hear from folks, especially folks who dot adopted interview intelligence technology early, is actually we're not seeing it change any outcomes. And I think there's a couple things behind that. First of all, people are not actually changing how they are making the hiring decision. They now have a better transcript. They now have a better AI-generated summary.
But no one is actually aligning that to this is what was talked about in the strategy setting meeting or the intake meeting with the hiring manager that they said was important. And does that person have that information or have those skills or or traits or not? And we know at Textio we did a research study two years ago that looked at over 10,000 hours of interviews. And it, you know, the net of it was you hire the people that you like. And I
This is where I also think there's such a huge opportunity for TA professionals because if you can be the person that has all the data that says, you know, we hired a hundred salespeople and I can look six to nine months later and actually say the 60% that are doing well are all have these things in common in terms of what they talked about or their experience or their traits that we observed. And these 40% maybe aren't making the cut.
And see if there's anything there. Like that is the keys to the kingdom for organization. And so I think just the definition of what a good process looks like isn't about did you get back to somebody in a timely fashion? Like that that's helpful for a candidate, but I think for an organization, that's not the outcome that I care about as a CEO or as a leader or or you know, a any leader in a company. They wanna know that I'm hiring the best people. And I think that the that's the part that's missing.
Rhona Pierce (08:00.75)
I was having a conversation, that's also in in the podcast feed with Matt Alder about this and and we were talking about and I wanna get your impression of this, a lot of what we've been solving for. We've thrown technology at hiring and we're fixing the hiring problem, but I think most of the problems that we're solving are like tactical level ones.
Colleen Gallagher (08:23.852)
Yeah. Yeah, I think it's I think there's been a lot of focus to this point on where can I, you know, optimize for efficiency. And that's great. But again, it just gives you some time savings. Maybe your time to fill goes down. But like your CEO probably doesn't care as much about time to fill as its own isolated measure. The only reason they're wanting you to get that faster is because they understand like low loss of productivity and all these things. But
It doesn't matter if you do that by bringing in people who are not qualified for the job. And I think there's also this misperception right now with the labor market that we're in that good talent is easier to find. And I think that that, you know, that also is very untrue because, you know, for for a lot of reasons, right? But there's just a mismatch in some of where the hiring is happening and and where you have high demand for roles.
Is similar across a lot of organizations. So people are still fighting for the best talent, but I do think that there's been a huge focus on efficiency because it feels the easiest to measure. And this concept around quality and quality of hire, nobody really knows how to measure it. No one's really cracked the code on it. And so I think, you know, and that's not to say that that's not a good first step, but I just think that there's more work to be done here.
Rhona Pierce (09:44.94)
I agree. What other challenges are you hearing TA folks talk about that they're having? Yes, efficiency and I think we're covered there. Yeah. What else are they saying?
Colleen Gallagher (09:57.292)
Yeah. I mean, I think they're saying, especially like I said, some of these early adopters, we actually are still making pretty significant we're we're having some problematic mishiring that they believed would have been captured by some of the transcription and summarization that is available in the market. And what it's done is it's made people actually more passive in the hiring process rather than
more active in the hiring process because, great, now it can it can write all my notes for me. And, you know, and we were guilty of this at Textio early on. One of the products that we that we built around this was how do we help people write better feedback? And obviously you can do that with AI. But the reality then and the reality now is people don't want to take the time to do that. And so now they just let AI summarize it and they don't proof it, right? They're not auditing it in a way that you need them to because
They're still making a recommendation based on like the vibes that they got during that process. And so that's where I think you can bring better AI and technology in that goes beyond some of those basic things.
Rhona Pierce (11:11.006)
One of the reasons why I'm so excited about what Textio has built with Lavalier is because you guys have always cared. I think at the core of Textio is removing bias from hiring. And do you think, like you were saying that people are more passive and stuff like that, or have we r reintroduced a lot of the bias that we had already removed from the process?
Colleen Gallagher (11:38.232)
I mean, yes, and I believe that we probably hadn't removed as much bias as we thought is actually the answer. But I definitely believe, especially with how prevalent fraud is in the space right now, obviously we could spend a whole hour talking about that and and we're not gonna get into that too much today. But I think w we're hearing the way people are fighting bias or fighting fraud is by, you know, saying, Well, these North Korean rings I'm not going to
interview people of Asian descent. And so yes, I think that there's a lot of that. I think it allows people to say, like, look, I got an A plus on submitting my scorecard and I can make sure that this passes any legal, you know, audit. If somebody wants a, you know, defensible hiring decision, we've got all the documentation, but it's like n no company solves for and nobody should be solving for what you need from a legal perspective, right? Even a lawyer will tell you the reason they have a job is for like
Looking around worst case scenario, that's not the way you run a business, right? The way you run a business is you want to make sure that people have the skills they need. And I think what it does allow you to do and to say is to say, this person actually demonstrated some of the things that we said were really important to have. And this person didn't. You're saying that you want to hire this the second person here. Did our requirements change? That's probably it, right?
Did we up level the role and the process and what, you know, what we actually wanted in terms of seniority was different? And we're just in a space right now where we can have a tool that will help us sort of iterate throughout the process on some of those things that end up being the most common challenges that people have.
Rhona Pierce (13:24.556)
Are your interviews giving you clear evidence of who can actually do the job? Textio in Kylin Co.'s new state of interview intelligence report reveals some uncomfortable gaps between how employers think they're doing and what's actually happening in hiring. Wanna see the findings for yourself? Download the full report at workfluencerpodcast.com slash textio. That's workfluencerpodcast.com slash textio. The link is in the show notes.
When you guys were building or are, 'cause it's actively being built, Lavalier, how did you guys think about this? Yeah, people are passive, yeah, there's like how did you think about how did you think about it?
Colleen Gallagher (14:08.46)
Yeah. I mean it's a it's a good question. I think we wanted to be intentional around making sure that we weren't just, you know, amplifying the problem. And so I think what that really does, what what that really means is you have to be clear about how someone has demonstrated some of the the skills that you said that you needed. And you have to give people coaching who are interviewing.
around how to do that and to get those questions out, right? Because most people who are doing interviewing, if you aren't at a company that can spend a year giving you interview training, or even if you have interview training, but somebody's sitting in this hour-long interview training and working in other things and not paying attention, right? We know that those types of ways of doing it are very ineffective. So what we really wanted to be intentional about and this was an outcome-based
Thinking for us. Like we wanted to do this intentionally, not to just differentiate our product in the market, but because it's the thing that's actually going to change the outcomes is giving you coaching in the moment. When somebody says, you know, I owned a demand gen for my company and this is what I did. Okay, well, tell me more about what that actually give me some examples. When how did it go wrong? What were some of the metrics that you looked at, right? Not everybody knows to just.
Ask those things in the moment or they will ask them, get an insufficient answer and move on because I don't really know how to do it in a way that's gonna follow up and get to those things. And that's where we have been really thoughtful about doing this. So it's not just, well, you know, we we talked about it, so they demonstrated it, which I think is what happens a lot with some of the summary just basic summarization.
Rhona Pierce (15:55.47)
How does it look or like what happens when a company takes this information? Because now we have this strong data and like does something with it. Yeah.
Colleen Gallagher (16:05.55)
Yeah, and I think this is this is what, you know, makes me really excited about this product because especially when I talk about my background in finance, right? I'm gonna get to your your question, but just as like a a a long way of getting there, right? Everyone loves a long answer. I think one of the challenges sitting from my finance perspective, especially with investment in HR, has often been you have sort of these like hand wavy things that you're talking about in terms of like, this is what I think might change, right? And in in the hiring space, we talk about like
The cost of a missed hire and just the loss of productivity and you try and quantify that and it always comes out to a big number. And I think that that's a really it's still the right sort of framework and thinking around it. The the challenge has always been that finance will often write that off because there's very little circling back to that 12 months later when the renewal comes up to say, like, did it actually impact that? Right. Because
Hiring markets change, your job, your hiring rate changes. so there's so many things that impact turnover rates and retention rates and things like that in an organization. And so you can never really tie those two things together. So to answer your question, the thing that excites me about this is you can use this data to make so many more data-driven decisions. And also as a TA leader, as a recruiter,
you know, move into the space of of actually helping to design and you know, coach people through the hiring process in a way where you're adding a lot of value because you can say, hey, look, again, you know, these were the things that actually worked in some of the hiring that we've done this year. Here are some of the things that didn't in terms of what people demonstrated and what they didn't. and you'll have data now that you can actually use to to show.
Rhona Pierce (17:59.342)
We are hearing a lot, well, I know I am and you probably are too, about interview intelligence as a category. What does that mean to you?
Colleen Gallagher (18:05.827)
Yeah.
Yeah, you know, it's interesting because I remember even before we launched Lavalier and we were talking about what's the category, you know, you're doing a lot of like product positioning and you're thinking a lot about all this stuff. And even at that time, I don't think interview intel it was still sort of this newer term and not everyone really knew what it was. And I think now a lot of people are using it and throwing that term around. You know, my strong belief on this is that what's getting grouped into interview intelligence.
There actually really needs to be, again, going back to like the efficiency versus quality, it's not interview intelligence if it's just sort of giving you a summary of what has happened. That's just that's interview recall, it's interview, you know, summarization. I think interview intelligence again goes back to this thing around, you know, not only can I give you information about if you if you think about what a lot of HR leaders and, you know, even functional leaders think about, we have these like this concept of.
Skills-based hiring and skills taxonomies. And the reality in an organization is none of that is coming from your interviews. And those are the best source of that data. The actual thing that happens is somebody starts on their first day and maybe they're in workday or whatever HRIS system, you know, the company has. And it's like, tell me if you have these traits, right? And you just you put some of them in. There's no verification. None of your performance reviews are based on any of that because those aren't the things that
ladder up to the company's goals and all that other kind of stuff. And so maybe you get 20% participation rate in these skills taxonomies. And as we see how the requirements of a job are evolving with things that come in and shock the system, like AI and the things that become more and more valuable. Or even if you want to, you're gonna hire, you have a role on your team, wouldn't you love an internal hire? But where can you go find that data? Because you have very little information on this person.
Colleen Gallagher (20:06.73)
Even their performance reviews are probably full of of, you know, personality bias, which Textio can help with too. But not the point. But so I think we just there's all these places where we could actually give a lot better information into the organization. And it, you know, interviews are just this black box right now. Even when you get the summaries, they're not aligned against anything. They just go and they, you know, they die in your ATS. There's such an opportunity there.
And that's what I think is the difference between intelligence, like true interview intelligence, because it helps level up your entire organization versus, you know, an efficiency play around, you know, interview recall.
Rhona Pierce (20:48.992)
In my brain it makes sense why Textio has moved into this space, but I want to hear from you. Why was it important? Like you guys started with like improving language and and the performance reviews and now you're in interview intelligence and true interview intelligence. Like why was it important for you guys to move this direction?
Colleen Gallagher (21:11.758)
So, you know, Texio is built on the conviction that your language matters and who you attract into an organization does have a lot to, you know, depends a lot on the language you use in job descriptions. And we continuously saw this with a lot of our customers is they would say, you know, we're getting more applicants, but we're not necessarily seeing that pattern flow all the way down into who we're actually hiring. Why is that?
And we would have a lot of conversations. Our first place we would go was often how you hire, there's many things that involve, you know, that are involved in that. If you are gonna bring in, you know, a a more diverse candidate pool, are you ensuring that the way that you're approaching your interview process is more diverse or or accurate in terms of how you're or standardized, right? So are you giving everyone the same interview experience?
And then we did that research report a couple of years ago where we saw, in fact, no, people are not getting a consistent interview experience. And there's a lot of bias around, you know, you just you hire the people that you like. And so that to us was just a key signal that said there's something happening in that interview process that you have to get better at assessing and standardizing and ensuring that you're, you know, making decisions with the data that you need.
And what we would hear from recruiters, what what often it started out as is I can't get anybody to write any feedback, right? Because that's still the day-to-day thing that if you're sitting in that seat and you're trying to chase people down, that's just the information that you need. You have that's the best way you're gonna get it. Right. But and so I think when we heard that early on, which is why we about a year and a half ago launched a product called interview feedback, which was really designed to help, you know, use our learning around everything we know about language.
both in recruiting and performance management, bring those two things together. And then what we continued to hear was we're not even getting people writing anything. So we, you know, we can't, it's not about changing the language. It's just about getting people to write things. So I do think that ties back to the instinct of folks to say, how can I get more efficient? How can I get even some visibility into what's happening? So again, there's no fault in starting there. But I think for us, what we also realized is that's just not going to solve the problem in the way that your leadership
Colleen Gallagher (23:38.778)
and is gonna benefit the organization because again, the the goal is not hiring faster. The goal is still to make sure you have the people that can do the right job. So this is where I think Textio, you know, sort of it sort of perfectly aligned with our experience to bring a product like Lavalier to market. I agree.
Rhona Pierce (23:58.222)
one thing that I w started thinking about as I read the report was just in conversations that I have, a lot of people hear structured interviews and they think robotic, everyone asks the same exact thing, don't go off script. And that's really the opposite of what Lavalier helps companies do. How did you guys think about this and get
Colleen Gallagher (24:24.59)
this. No, that's such a great, a great takeaway too, I think, because we're not trying to make people read from a screen and sound really robotic. The thing that is unique about it and that is so important is that the thing you're trying to do is not actually ask verbatim the same questions to every single candidate. Not everybody communicates the same way. Not everyone questions or interprets them the same way. What you're really trying to get to is
This is the thing I said I needed to assess and how can I do that? And that's where our live guidance really helps because I might ask a question in a way that elicits a response from you that's very easy to understand. And I might say it the exact same way to somebody else, and I don't really get what I'm looking for. And we can help give you that language and give you the words. And so it's less about, you know, I asked questions one through four and some I asked some version of it.
However, I got there to assess the thing that I'm looking for, not just check a, you know, check a box and answer a question. I was talking to somebody ahead of TA recently, and she was showing me, you know, they using AI have a way to auto-populate, like, what did a candidate say to this question? And I sort of like cringed a little because.
It's not about you know, my question back was like, well, how do you assess whether or not they actually have the skill, not whether or not they answered your question. And so that to me is again another example of of the disconnect, but also, you know, did come out in in some of the survey results as well that, you know, people don't want it's not about structure, it's just about assessing for skills and outcomes.
Rhona Pierce (26:08.954)
And I think really that's gonna help with this gap in perception with the candidates. Because it like you said, it wasn't about I didn't get the job and that's why I think there's that it wasn't a good process. It's more of like I didn't feel that it was fair. Yeah. And I think when you ask a question where you're seeing the person for who they are and you're digging in deep, they're I mean, I know I would be like, they really wanted to get to know me and they really did everything they could to try to get me to answer. Like
Colleen Gallagher (26:38.37)
Yeah. And I think too, another aspect to this is, you know, we we all know one of the biggest challenges for recruiters is scheduling, right? And we also know that people who end up sitting on the interview panel are they they think of often think about hiring as a second job. They'll look at questions, you know, two minutes before, probably forget some of them. And the reality isn't about who the it shouldn't be about who the interviewer is.
It should be about the substance of the interview itself. So that if it's you or I interviewing a candidate, they get, you know, even if it's three different candidates and three different interviewers, you're still getting the signal that you need out of that and consistency across that, not because, you know, somebody read some questions in Slack two minutes before an interview, because we're coaching each, you know, three individual people and three individual candidates in a way that's gonna
actually elicit the thing we want from
Rhona Pierce (27:41.87)
Kind of to wrap up, if interview intelligence delivers on its promise, what changes for talent acquisition? How does it look in the future? It's a good
Colleen Gallagher (27:50.744)
Question. The biggest thing for me, and I've I've heard this concept a lot recently, and in talking to a lot of the TA leaders that I have the opportunity to talk to, I hear a lot there's this desire to make sure that TA professionals are not seen as order takers. And the, you know, some of the things I've heard recently is like maybe a better way to say that is people, but it's it's meant to be positive, is like.
The a recruiter should be the quarterback. And I don't believe that's true. I believe the quarter the the recruiter needs to be the coach. Like you're deciding who the slate of candidates are. You are deciding a lot in conjunction, right? You're taking feedback from the hiring manager. But again, this is where, like, as a talent acquisition leader or recruiter, you are the subject matter expert in hiring. And so I think it's about how do we there is some efficiency stuff.
In that, right? How do we make sure that you're not chasing people down for feedback and putting a bunch of questions together? Absolutely is what that is what is going to give you time to do this. But I think again, this is the thing that you you have to do. This function ends up being somebody to say to a hiring manager, you know, when I look at like your team and the past 10 people that you've hired in this organization, the thing that, you know, is is true about all your top performers.
Is they exhibited X, and Z during the interview process. And that allows you to be the strategic advisor. It allows you to be the coach or, you know, whatever you know, whatever analogy you want to look at. But I I don't think that the future of being a TA leader or a recruiter is to be a quarterback where you're just running a place somebody else is calling for you. You're not there to be because frankly, like
With AI, I I just don't see that being a role that companies are going to pay for long term. What they're going to pay for is the human element, the human thought leadership, the thinking around all of this, where you are actually saying, you know, here's what I think and here's the data. And that's just been the huge gap that hasn't been there because again, interviews have been this black box. And and it's not about just, I got a summary, and so here's what I know. You know, you have to tie that into performance outcomes.
Colleen Gallagher (30:08.79)
And that's what I think makes people much more relevant. And that's where I I see the talent acquisition role and just function really moving forward. And I everyone I talk to who loves doing what they're doing, that's what they see as well. And that's where they want to be, right? I don't I don't think a lot of people have come into this profession because they wanna just do what other people are telling them. Yeah. Nor do I think that the the best recruiters are doing that, right? I think that we've just
ask them to do something that's very hard, which is advise people with zero data, almost zero data. Yeah. And so I I I do think that there's a real opportunity for people to be the coach.
Rhona Pierce (30:49.31)
I I'm excited for for the present. I I was gonna say the future, but really it's happening now. It it's true. It's the present. So I'm excited for it 'cause yeah, remembering my day sitting, th this is what we wanted. This you want the data to be able to to be that coach. Yeah. So I've really enjoyed this conversation. Where can listeners connect with
Colleen Gallagher (31:08.246)
You I'm on LinkedIn like everyone in this space. I think I've been on it long enough that I have the like, you know, LinkedIn dot com slash Colleen Gallagher. So that's me.
Rhona Pierce (31:20.142)
Perfect. And we'll include that in the show notes. Thank you so much for being on the show too. Thank you. Yay. So here's the question I want to leave you with. Are your interviews giving you clear evidence of who can actually do the job? If today's conversation has you questioning that, Textio and Kylan Co.'s State of Interview Intelligence Report is worth digging into. Download the full report at workfluencerpodcast.com/slash textio and see how your own hiring process stacks up against the findings.
The link is in the show notes. Thanks for listening and I'll chat with you next week.
CEO
Colleen is a CEO who built her career across finance, operations, and go-to-market functions. She has scaled SaaS companies, led revenue and operations, and partnered with boards and investors on capital strategy, M&A, and market expansion.
She now leads Textio in building AI systems for the future of hiring—structured, defensible, and outcome-driven.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
YouTube
PocketCasts
Overcast 